Dining & Clubs

Get Listed! Do you have a club or restaurant? List it here today. Do you want to update your listing below? Contact a sales representative at 914-844-7490 or email us here.

Restaurants

Floyd's
A gourmet sandwich shop. At present, the only restaurant offering a full breakfast. All baking is done on premises. Open 7 days a week starting at 7 a.m. Located next to A Summer Place Realty

Cherry Grove Pizza
The best pizza on the island - and delicious Italian specialties. Dine in or Take out!
Located across from Joseph's Grocery Store in the Beach Hotel Complex.
Phone: 631-597-6766

Rachel's/Jack's Place
The only restaurant facing the ocean on Fire Island. Unbelievable views, great food & fantastic blender drinks. A Piano Bar is being added this season.
Phone: 631-597-4174

Burger Queen (Joseph's)
This 7 year old grocery is adding a Grill this season. The Burger Queen will feature the first $5.00 burger with all the fixin's in the Grove. Franks, Gyros, Shrimp sandwiches & lots more. Bring your appetite!
Phone: 631-597-9210

Cherry's Pit
This restaurant and bar is a popular grove gathering place. Great food but not the most generous of portions. Cherry's Pit has a great second floor deck for outdoor seating and a wonderful view of the bay and the famous sunset.
Phone: 631-597-6820

Top of the Bay
Expensive and worth it, the prices compare to Manhattan. The atmosphere is perfect with paned glass overlooking the bay on two sides. We suggest dining in the outdoor area farthest to the rear, however it gets chilly so bring a sweater or long sleeve shirt. Crab cakes, pasta or steak, they have it all and it's damn good.
Phone: 631-597-6699.

Clubs & Bars

Cherry's
A popular place for benefits and charity parties Cherry's has a great reputation for fun and community building. The bay side deck is one of Cherry Grove's best views of the sunset, people tend to flock here as the sun paints the summer sky.
Phone: 631-597-6820.

The Ice Palace
This is cherry grove's premier night spot. Incredible drag shows and theme parties. The bar has a large deck on one side, and a indoor/outdoor pool on the other. With a cool lounge, hot dance floor, and billiards tables you can't go wrong.
Phone: 631-597-6600.

Sunsets
Located right on the bay for uninterrupted sunset views. This hot spot is popular with straight visitors from other fire island communities. Theme nights draw a big crowd. Female impersonators are featured every Sunday night, and male strippers take it all off every Saturday night. Female strippers show their stuff on the last Sunday of the month. You can also catch stand-up comics performing here occasionally, and about 25 to 30 drag shows a summer. The bar serves light snacks such as popcorn and chips. No cover charge.
Phone: 631-597-9663.

Pines Place
Conveniently located seven walks from the harbor which
is only a few short minutes by foot. Located on a quiet walk just one
house off the ocean. Guests can enjoy beautiful ocean views and breezes
that make Fire Island so special. The light and airy guest rooms vary
between shared baths, private baths and deluxe rooms with ocean views!
All the rooms connect to a common living area and kitchen where guest
can cook if they wish to do so. The atmosphere at Pines Place is
always friendly and relaxed, where guest can experience morning conversation during the breakfast buffet and often spend the day together in the sun chaises surrounding the pool. The evening cocktail hour provides further chance to finalize dinner and club plans.
Phone: 631-597-6162
pinesplace.com